How Did the Author Make You Like That Character?

You might have wondered why I rarely write about the nuts and bolts of the writing craft. Generally I can answer a question about writing, and then I’m off and running. But basically my mind and soul do not run in that direction. I am fascinated and experienced in the act of creativity itself. That is my gift. And I encourage myself by encouraging others.

But the other day, my friend and writer, Mary Ann, wanted to know how a fiction writer created a character that a reader liked immediately. I replied with the old saw, “If you want a reader to like the character, have him rescue a dog. If you want them to hate the character, have him kick the dog.”

This exact tool was recently used in the television show ‘Person of Interest’. Have you seen it? It can be quite violent, was leaning almost too much so for me, but then they brought in a dog for the lead characters. The ultra-tough main character, John Reese, saved the dog. We love him for it. The dog was needed to give a soft side to the people–we all love that dog and the men’s reactions to him. We love them for loving the dog, and because the dog loves them.

Back to the discussion at hand–Mary Ann went on to say that she was reading A Caribbean Mystery, by Agatha Christie. We agreed to favoring Christie’s earlier works, and Mary Ann found this one, published in 1964, not one of the Dame’s best, but worthy of reading. Christie was a master in making a character likable, even those who turned out to be the perpertrator of the dirty deed, which I think may be cheating a bit, but Mary Ann and I both delight in Christie’s command of language and classy tone (and all that tea drinking that goes on in her stories.)

Mary Ann said she liked Miss Marple on the first page of the book. Why? Was it because Miss Marple listened to the old man, and Mary Ann likes that about a person? I’m sure that’s a huge part of it.

Intrigued, I decided to read A Caribbean Mystery with Mary Ann and to dust off some of the gray cells of old knowledge about drawing character, which is my absolutely favorite thing to do. I’m having such a good time rediscovering the art of drawing character that thought I’d share my observations with you.

  • First off, I want to point out that a reader is prepared to like the main character before ever opening the novel. That’s why they picked up the novel. You have a reader’s attention and good will at the outset on that point. The only way a reader will not like a character, and therefore a book, is if you blow creating a character to root for. I cannot tell you how many novels I’ve put down because I did not care about the heroine/hero. I want to like them, and for them to take me away from my own world.
  • In the first paragraph of A Caribbean Mystery, Christie gives us an old military man–Major Palgrave–reminiscing. We hear his British accent and age in the dialogue. The second paragraph, one sentence: Old Miss Marple inclined her head. That’s it. She didn’t turn her head, she didn’t sigh, she didn’t interrupt or correct. We see her listening to an old man. That is the loving the dog with respect. Who doesn’t love to be listened to? Who doesn’t admire a listener.
  • In the following paragraph, Christie elaborates on this theme, on what Miss Marple is offering the old man, and how she is cleverly able to be respectful and kind, while really not listening at all. Oh, we love the cleverness. We’ve all done this, from young to old. In these paragraphs we learn Miss Marple has experience, is wise and kind and very human. We admire her.
  • Further down the second page and onto the third, we are looking through Miss Marple’s thoughts at her life, at who she is, a spinster, obviously, with a doting nephew, who always wants to improve her. He loves her, so we’re prone to love her, and she loves him, and we love her for loving him. Here’s a key: if you want a character to be lovable, have someone else in the story love them. Again, I have to say almost anyone of any generation can relate to this.
  • Then for me there is a sentence that leaps out: “Modern novels. So difficult–all about such unpleasant people, doing such very odd things and not, apparently, even enjoying them.” Funny! Enlivening, revealing. I connect. I feel the exact same way about modern novels, here nearly fifty years after the book was first published.

Agatha Christie was a master at both character and plot. I’m continuing on with the book with an eye to character and invite you to join Mary Ann and I, and share your observations, if you’re so inclined. I’ll try to post on this topic again next week.

Keep writing, about anything and everything. That’s how you find out who you are.


13 thoughts on “How Did the Author Make You Like That Character?

  1. You are so terribly smart. I’m honored to know you. You intuitively knew exactly what all of us thought. I recently read that book, and a little further along, we discover that no one on the island likes the major. They all dismiss him, and we’re pretty sure they are all bad people. Sometimes, Christie also makes you dislike all the characters. Only later are a couple of them redeemed.

    Thanks for writing on writing. I’ve been thinking about all of this a great deal. One more thing . . . Christie was a master of human behavior. She understood people.~~Dee


    • Oh, dear one, thank you for that observation. I had not seen that. Only Miss Marple had patience and understanding for the major. What is hilarious for me is that I skimmed, twice, the initial references to the glass eye. She did very much understand people. I surprised myself by liking Evelyn, sort of a younger version of Miss Marple. xxooo, CurtissAnn


  2. James Byrd, small framed man with dark hair, mustache and goatee. He was different! He taught classic literature, read such books as Moby Dick, and Wuthering Heights, and Of Mice and Men. Guess I remember more about that class than I thought!!! If you don’t remember him, I’m sure hubby does! Even those who didn’t have him, knew him!


  3. WOW, I have never thought that concept through before. You are a wonderful teacher! While reading the post and thnking of you as a teacher, I had an immediate flashback to a certain high school English teacher, pacing back and forth across the front of the classroom asking the question, ” Why did the author feel that it was important to tell you that there was a blooming rose bush near the prison door in The Scarlet Letter?” This teacher had a way of making you “think” while reading a book. You help us to “think” about our writing as well! Bless You!


  4. Agatha Christie was a genius at creating full characters within simple gesture or a disapproving glance. She was also a master at plotting and voice.

    I’ve tried out dozens of mystery writers and no one quite measures up.

    Thanks for the great post!


  5. Wow – what an insightful post. I never stopped to think about why I like the characters that I do…what skill or craft went behind creating that person…and, as a writer and reviewer, I should be doing just that. Thanks for helping me understand the process a bit better!


    • I had not thought about it all in so long, just have gone on instinct. But I’m seeing with a fresh eye, and ways to improve my characters, and it is so much fun! Thanks for the encouragement.


Thoughts? Don't keep them to yourself. Love to hear!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.